Review - Girl Meets God

Girl Meets God by Lauren F. Winner

My rating: 2 of 5 stars

Another book that I just couldn't get through... although Lauren is a great teacher (took a writing class from her), and I've read snippets of her other books which were excellent, this was one I couldn't get into. It's very introspective and just goes on and on and on, with a writing style that got on my nerves. The style is very forced, like she is trying too hard to pattern her sentences the same way most of the time.

I like the setup of the book, though--the division into vignettes that have to do with various religious seasons. However, I think the chronological setup of the seasons was deceptive since she did not relate her story entirely chronologically. Maybe that wasn't the point, and the vignettes were just supposed to go along with the themes of the various seasons, but it left me pretty confused about what was happening after what.

Maybe I also couldn't get into it because I don't know a lot about Judaism. I could identify with her spiritual experience in the sense of converting from one worldview to another--in my case, agnostic to Christian--but I couldn't really identify with her spiritual anguish in choosing one faith over another, since I have never identified with another faith as strongly as I have with Christianity. Oh well. I suppose some books just don't speak to some people.

View all my reviews